Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

How does claim frequency harm your ability to get new insurance?

September 30th, 2026

3 min read

By Dolan Jablonski

How does claim frequency harm your ability to get new insurance?

Quick answer

Frequent claims can make it harder and more expensive to get new insurance. Insurers see repeated claims as higher risk, which can mean higher premiums, denial of coverage, cancellation, or non-renewal. Weigh whether filing a claim is worth a possible premium increase, and talk with your agent before deciding.

This article explains how frequent insurance claims can negatively impact your ability to obtain new insurance by increasing perceived risk, leading to higher premiums, denial of coverage, or policy cancellations. It highlights the role of risk assessment, underwriting criteria, and loss history reports in this process, and offers strategies to minimize claim frequency and maintain good insurer relationships.

Key Takeaways:

  • Frequent claims increase your risk profile, making insurers more likely to charge higher premiums or deny coverage.
  • Loss history reports showing repeated claims can cause insurers to cancel or not renew your policy.
  • Minimize unnecessary claims by weighing the cost of filing against potential premium increases or coverage loss.
  • Working with an insurance agent can help you understand your options and manage risk to maintain insurability.

Claim frequency can affect your ability to obtain new insurance in a few ways:

  1. Risk Assessment: All insurance companies assess risk when determining whether to provide coverage to an individual or property. If you have a history of frequent claims, insurers may perceive you as a higher risk. This perception stems from the likelihood that you may continue to file claims in the future, which can be costly for the insurer.
  2. Underwriting Criteria: Insurers use underwriting criteria or matrix to evaluate applicants for insurance coverage. A history of frequent claims may cause you to be categorized as a higher-risk applicant, which can result in higher premiums or even denial of coverage.
  3. Loss History Reports: Insurers use loss history reports, which contain information about previous insurance claims associated with a property or individual. If your loss history report shows a pattern of frequent claims, insurers may be more hesitant to offer you coverage.
  4. Policy Cancellation or Non-Renewal: In some cases, insurers may choose to cancel your policy or not renew it if you have a history of frequent claims. This can leave you scrambling to find coverage elsewhere, and being labeled as a high-risk applicant can make it more challenging to obtain new insurance at an affordable rate.

To mitigate the impact of claim frequency on your ability to obtain insurance, it’s essential to try to minimize unnecessary claims. Consider whether the cost of filing a claim outweighs the potential increase in premiums or loss of coverage in the future. Additionally, maintaining a good relationship with your insurer and practicing risk management to prevent future losses can also be beneficial. The importance of having an insurance agent as council and advisor is paramount in these situations. Our job is to provide all applicable information to our insureds, while offering advice, so they can make the best decision in the short and long term.

claims

Keep Reading

Frequently asked questions

Can filing too many insurance claims get me denied coverage?

Yes, it can. Insurers use underwriting criteria to evaluate applicants, and a history of frequent claims may place you in a higher-risk category, resulting in higher premiums or even denial of coverage. Your agent can explain how this may apply to your situation.

What is a loss history report?

A loss history report contains information about previous insurance claims associated with a property or individual. Insurers use these reports, and if yours shows a pattern of frequent claims, insurers may be more hesitant to offer you coverage.

Can my insurer cancel or non-renew my policy because of claims?

In some cases, yes. Insurers may cancel or not renew a policy if you have a history of frequent claims. That can leave you scrambling to find coverage elsewhere, and being labeled high-risk can make affordable coverage harder to find.

Should I file a small insurance claim?

We suggest considering whether the cost of filing a claim outweighs the potential increase in premiums or loss of coverage in the future. We recommend minimizing unnecessary claims, and talking with an insurance agent first to understand your options in both the short and long term.

How can I protect my ability to get insurance if I've had claims?

We recommend minimizing unnecessary claims, maintaining a good relationship with your insurer, and practicing risk management to prevent future losses. An insurance agent can also serve as counsel and advisor, providing information and advice so you can make the best decision.

Dolan Jablonski